I think something similar was at work in the star wars prequels. It now holds the record for the longest time spent researching and writing any single article on tifo by a very good margin. Yet the most admired of all things star wars were the movie. Speaking of which, neither the star trek reboots nor the star wars prequels have any idea what their tone is supposed to be. On this weeks podcast, jack obrien is joined by cracked executive editor jason pargin aka david wong for a deep dive into the history of star wars and how we got to this very moment. Here are the top 10 reasons the star wars prequels sucked. Welcome back to katharine remembers the good and bad about star wars tiein novels of the 90s. And seeing as how the folks in charge of star wars are the ones who grew up on it, the new films feel a smidge unadventurous at times. Star wars, episode i was the most anticipated movie ever, and will probably go down as the most anticipated movie in all of history. Im out of step with the mainstream because i hold george lucas in high regard and i prefer the innovation, ideas and idiosyncrasies of his prequels to disneys more polished and socially. The star wars prequels are also much suckier than some of the movies you have on here. The first film in that series, episode i, is actually listed in the top twenty box office successes of all time.
To believe the conventional wisdom, the prequel trilogy of the star wars saga 1999s episode i. Episode i the phantom menace 1999 september 25, 2015 2. As we drink in the new star wars film, there are some things from the series previous instalments that well be hoping not to see. But on whole, star wars fans like the phantom menace, attack of the clones, and revenge of the sith. Every star wars movie ranked, including the rise of skywalker. While george lucas was the man behind star wars from the beginning he only directed the first film in the original trilogy. For more extended universe shaming, check out 6 star wars characters too retarded for film.
Anakins thoughts while being burned on mustafar and turning into darth vader star wars explained duration. Perhaps the most annoying part of the star wars prequels is the relationship between padme and anakin. Now think of how badly it sucks when someone told you the final. The best version of the star wars prequels is still the.
After what feels like an eternity of waiting, star wars. The star wars prequels have a different structure than the original trilogy. Prequels are an inherently bad idea, and they are generally executed in a manner that makes them even worse, retreading imagery from the movies ostensibly after them as selfimportant foreshadowing, and glibly trading in self. Mar, 2018 all the first six star wars movies are available in a big complete set. The prequels sucked, but my god, at least they tried.
The prequels were hated by an entire generation of star wars fans. Episode i the phantom menace 1999, episode ii attack of the clones 2002, and. Star trek the original series is very much for adults. And while art is obviously subjective, as a fan of the movie and with the movie now available on streaming, this seemed as good a time as any to try to rebut at least some of the. Im excited for the new star wars despite awful prequels. Some star wars devotees consider the last jedi among the best of the franchise.
The ultimate news source for music, celebrity, entertainment, movies, and current events on the web. The rise of skywalker is an exciting and actionpacked space adventure. The same people who will call this pennywise scarier than the last are the people who said the star wars prequels were better because they had more light sabers in them. Even the hobbit prequels to the lord of the ring series dont score much above the star wars prequels, and yet no one feels betrayed, by those films. Naive and enthusiastic, and he shouldve wisecracked to his opponents like spiderman. Nice that someone made the effort to combine the videos. We have covered my favorites, the worst book to actually matter, and proof that luke. Star wars fandom has finally got over the prequels thanks to disney. Why the star wars prequels sucked, and why it matters by. While its not the star wars film to ends all star wars films, star wars. I use the term relationship lightly, as it feels more like a teenage girls star wars fanfiction than an actual adult relationship.
Abrams is at the controls, and his crack at the star trek franchise. What should george lucas have done differently with the star wars. For more, check out how to fix the worst moment in all of star wars and 5 things star wars fans dont understand about star wars. The star wars prequels will eventually look so different than the other 20 some star wars movies and counting that people will start to like them for just how nutty they are. And the darth vader outfit was the holy grail of halloween costumes. A prequel crushes this tension right from the get go. A tough call, as hes not wrong, but at the same time the original trilogy does represent something of an anchor for the brand. Rogue one has been called a lot of thingsa star wars story, an anthology film, a standalone adventuremany of which are synonyms for prequel. Mark hamill cant believe how intensely people bashed the star wars. Last night, the third trailer for the upcoming star wars. The prequels get a lot of hate, but im fairly confident that any star wars fan in the 2030 age demographic can attribute it to the prequels. I think its the dialogue and character interactions that sucked. Vader would have been no match for yoda and yet yoda hides out on dagobah. With the prequels, he traded the integrity of the original trilogy for lowestcommon denominator crap that the kidlets would clap their popsicle.
The trilogy was released from 1999 to 2005 and is a prequel to the original star wars trilogy 197783. The star wars prequel trilogy is a series of epic spaceopera films written and directed by george lucas. If i want to see star wars in 3d ill drink nyquil and cherry 7 up. Yes, i know lucas had very good ideas and strong themes in place for them, but in film, its all about the script, the script, and the script, and the script sucked. For all of the thrills of the original star wars trilogy, theyre ultimately fairly simple stories. May 04, 2016 on this weeks podcast, jack obrien is joined by cracked executive editor jason pargin aka david wong for a deep dive into the history of star wars and how we got to this very moment. Theres an inherent goofiness to everything, and some episodes like spocks brain are downright farcical, but for the most part, its heady science fiction. The top 10 reasons why the star wars prequels sucked. The main forward momentum of disneys star wars is the sequel trilogy the force awakens, the last jedi, and the untitled episode ix and if the prequels are going to be canonized in fans eyes then its here where the groundwork needs to be laid. Bladewolf101 is a fanfiction author that has written 10 stories for inheritance cycle, batman, percy jackson and the olympians, jurassic park, wrestling, godzilla, avengers, fairy tail, spiderman, venom, and supergirl.
Like most children of the 1980s, i grew up surrounded by star wars. Same thing goes for wolverine, cyclops, sabertooth and stryker in origins. How one star wars fan rewrote the prequels and did it. With the upcoming rerelease of the phantom menace in cinemas converted to 3d, and with the rerelease of all six star wars films in 3d due over the next six years, i thought this an opportune moment to reassess the star wars prequel trilogy with the benefit of hindsight, and to expound on how i would have made them differently. The sequels ultimately turning out to be a disappointment after a strong start doesnt change how much i loathe and despise the prequels. In palpatines office, a crack team of the toppest most masterful jedi alive come by to. They discuss what the original trilogy got right, where the prequels went wrong, and the complicated genius of. Spiderman 3 and i am legend are each 10 times more entertaining than listening to the fucky dialogue in star wars prequels. They discuss what the original trilogy got right, where the prequels went wrong, and the complicated genius of george lucas. Id rather watch the phantom menace a hundred times than this even.
Sure, i enjoyed the crude richie and eddie humor, and thought it was wellcast for the most part. Avgn states that the first star wars game on the atari. But by the end i was almost yawning through the pennywise scenes. George lucas had an odd idea for his star wars sequel trilogy. I actually like the star wars prequels nerds on earth. There were many outer space or galaxy movies, but most were cheesy, b. Star wars films being rereleased in 3d the marquee blog. For those of you who arent in the know somehow, the star wars prequels came out between 1999 and 2005. Top 10 reasons why the star wars prequels are hated youtube. That movie sucked so hard and i was pissed because i loved the 3 ones before that so much. Spielberg and lucas can add as many prequels, sequels, cartoons, video games, cereal boxes, etc they want. What went wrong with the star wars prequels, and how i. The fight between quigon and darth maul on tatooine is one such example of this but in the phantom menace, it gets better.
The rise of skywalker spoiler thread page 12 star wars. Only reason im fine with it is because star wars the clone wars that was the good parts of the prequels good story good everything there were some let downs mainly in season 1 but that was the start it became probably one of the best shows of all time. I think more so than anything, the films have a staggering amount of nuance that is often. Star wars, the emperor strikes back, return of the jedithe. The lightsaber fights in the prequels, at least when it comes to choreography, are far superior to their original trilogy counterparts. But the people saying this movie killed star wars are absolutely correct because that is what it was trying to do. Without phantom menace, i would not be a huge star wars fan. While there are elements that rhyme, like the way anakin destroys the droid control ship and qui gons death, it.
Very recently, the title of the next installment in the star wars series was leaked to the public. Star wars fans have forgiven the prequels thanks to disney. Not as good as star wars or empire, but better than jedi. Pt the phantom menace pt 4k upscaled a minor revelation. The force awakens is the most anticipated movie of 2015, and its essential that we make sure the next star wars installment gets it right. Not only that, but the first star wars game ever and the first licensed movie video game for a home console system the star wars arcade game came out in 1983. Before you take up your torches and pitchforks hear me out. And little is worse than hayden christiensens jawdroppingly bad performance as anakin skywalker. The star wars sequels will be memed into popularity a. The last jedi, as number eight will be titled, is an ominous and promising title. But you dont need it to be a movie with sword fights for a prequel to suck. Well probably regard it as a largely missed opportunity due to seriously poor planning regardless of how positively or negatively weve felt about the films themselves.
When it comes to simon pegg, i just wish he didnt go out of his way to bash the prequels and instead focused on the parts he loved. Star wars fans are massively downvoting antiprequel. When jurassic park hit theaters in 1993, it proved beyond any doubt that computers could generate graphics so. And stop by our top picks to see seanbaby kicking our george lucas cutout right in the cardboard. Lor san tekkas mention of balance in the force wasnt just a wink towards to. I was most bothered by the lack of sincerity in this movie that was in the original trilogyand even in the prequels beneath the poor script.
In fact, the entire third act of clones, from the arena fight to the first clone war battle to anakin and padmes secret wedding, is the greatest contribution the prequels make to the star wars. In defense of the sheer ambition of these prequels, which come arguably closest to what a space opera should be. But i can tell you as a fan that doesnt like the prequels, but rather as a fan that loves the prequels, i hate it when people give me hyperbolic, pre. The prequels give us a more nuanced look at the morality of the star wars universe, and suggest that good people can fall from grace. Star wars prequel trilogy is one one the most hated series of films on the internet, but there are two sides to every story. Despite all of the complaints, what went right in the star wars prequels. Episode vii the force awakens was an exercise in nostalgia that worked so well because of three factors. Search, watch, and cook every single tasty recipe and video ever all in one place. Star wars podcasts for the podcasting jedi podcasting pro. Let go of your hate fear leads to anger, bla bla bla. Still, to be fair to the haters, the star wars prequels might not make it easy on the casual viewer. Why do people not like the star wars prequel trilogy. Since most things star wars have sucked so far, wouldnt that just make these new movies look greater by comparison no matter how bad they. Support cracked s journalism with a visit to our contribution page.
That also means i was still a child when episode 1 came out. Sep 03, 2011 indy 4 is like the star wars prequels, i dont have to acknowledge their existence. New star wars documentary attempts to defend the prequels. We wont look back at star wars disney era fondly at all. That means i only ever saw star wars at home and not in the theater. The star wars prequels were roundly criticised for being overly preoccupied with political maneuvering, but the force awakens went too far in the other direction. Star wars was the first movie i ever saw at the cinema aged 4 apparently bambi might have preceded that, but i choose to forget that because its shit, and i remember going to watch all three backtoback at my local odeon with staff dressed in costume. Why i love the star wars prequels and you should too.
Top 10 reasons why the star wars prequels are hated subscribe. Sure the prequels sucked but it was all one vison from geroge. I like the nostalgiacritics videos but the top 11 good things in the star wars prequels are very superficial compared to the points made by plinkett. The second act of the clone wars grinds to an uninteresting halt and never recovers only to get bogged down further with the stilted romance. What was darth vaders origin before the star wars prequels. George lucas to continue killing star wars in bluray release. As an 11 year old, i thought phantom menace was the greatest thing ever. The second best star wars movie, only behind return of the jedi.
Sep 29, 2010 no one would notice except that they might actually be better. Clearly there are people who disagree, and thats fine. Its not cool to hate the star wars prequels anymore. You look me in the eye and tell me this doesnt look like a teenagers fanfiction. The rise of skywalker is the kind of thing that happens when a singular voice creates a revolutionary trilogy that changes movies forever and becomes a cultural phenomenon beloved by generations and then years later makes a trilogy of prequels to said movies that are also a cultural phenomenon and also change movies forever in a different way but are disdained by many and after a. Jun, 2018 star wars was always intended to be an epic. It harkens back to the sense of pure fun, imagination and excitement that characterised the classic movie serials and pulp space fantasy adventures that inspired the star wars saga. Our mega list of fascinating star wars facts you probably didnt know if youve noticed the fewer number of articles being published the last couple weeks on tifo, this post is the cause. I was 11 years old in 1997 when i discovered my love of star wars with the release of the special edition movies in theaters, and i promptly started. In fact, to my surprise, it has a bafflingly low score on rotten tomatoes.
Star wars sprang forth from humanity, and humanity loved it to death. Jun 16, 2017 the official star wars website announced the title attack of the clones with the following description in august 2001. With that latest star wars movie now available for digital download, we thought that we would take a crack at our own ranking of star wars movies. If youre not familiar with my take on the star wars, im a devout follower, but a heretic. For staunch star wars nerds burnt out by years of jackass expanded universe stories, adding to the star wars canon sometimes feels like writing new chapters to the bible wherein jesus comes back to fight isis with the aid of a talking car. Please be aware this article contains many spoilers. Others rank it somewhere between the holiday special and that time donny and marie conquered the empire using the power of disco. This movie went downhill as soon as jarjar stepped into it. Star wars was always a sincere filmsaga that never cared to conform to the mainstreams of hollywood.
Join me on my high horse, as i explore just 15 of the innumerable ways the star wars prequels sucked. Use this list to call for a more inclusive galaxy, not a more racist, misogynistic one. In star wars episodes i through iii we know that anakin, yoda, obiwan, palpatine, r2d2 and c3po all have to be alive at the end. My top 10 changes to the star wars prequel trilogy mr. The 3 people george lucas first asked to direct the star. Tfa is by far the worst star wars movie in the franchise, and is in fact one of the worst movies i have ever seen in my life. Darksaber teaches many lessons about what not to do in star wars. Why the star wars prequels suck part 1 of 4 youtube. Episode vi return of the jedi 1983 no one had seen anything like it. Top 10 reasons why star wars sucked or yep, jj abrams and. Or check out some laughable races from star trek because, well, we like to cover our nerdy bases here at cracked. Jan 02, 2017 george lucas illadvised star wars prequels continue to linger painfully in fans memories.
Dec 17, 2019 iger on the other end wants to push the franchise in a new direction. They are objectively bad movies, with bad pacing, nonsensical character arcs, and a mix of wooden and exaggerated acting except ewan mcgregor he was great. People dont hate the star wars prequels because they are. When it came time for the prequel trilogy however, lucas famously, or. The original trilogy was a watershed, and altered the way movies were made, how people went to movies and changed the imagination of an entire generation now, generations of moviegoers. As any good star wars fan knows, may the 4th marks star wars day, aka may the 4th be with you a day to commemorate all things star wars. As long as you love something star wars, even if its not the same part of star wars that i love, you are a star wars fan and dont ever let anyone tell you otherwise. Top 10 reasons why star wars sucked or yep, jj abrams and disney are the. I do agree with james rolfe that the revenge of the sith was a decent movie and the only one you need to see to get the gist of the entire prequel. If you hated the star wars prequels you probably werent paying attention.
They were written from the perspective of someone watching a series of movies and then intentionally inverting things to be different. Not even christopher lee as a sith lord could save it. When the last jedi finally hit theaters we got our answer, which turned. It was the movie of my youth, the movie i spent countless hours reenacting as a kid. Dec 16, 2017 in this video i explore the major storytelling contradictions and flaws in the last jedi, and why i think it has killed the new star wars trilogy. Being the best movie in the star wars prequel trilogy isnt exactly a high. If you hated the star wars prequels you probably werent. Star wars toys, books and magazines littered my room. He is basically evil so that from a narrative perspective. Our mega list of fascinating star wars facts you probably. Buy why the star wars prequels sucked, and why it matters by delano lopez ebook online at lulu. What the seven star wars films reveal about george lucas.
It isnt for me to say how you should feel about them. Dec 20, 2015 speaking of which, neither the star trek reboots nor the star wars prequels have any idea what their tone is supposed to be. The other two also did very profitable business at the box office as well. How could darth vaders origin story have been told better than it. They were widely hated and derided by everyone, including the media and fans.
1513 1203 154 1099 1532 638 90 1354 418 876 944 1470 898 806 1416 799 402 355 137 662 117 905 217 48 192 1488 299 481 1465 281 765 720 900 1115 552 215 1022 1145 701 867 227 352 552 378 1039 262 315 1248 1285 1402